That’s the day I met him. I know that because I pulled out my journal to see what I had written about him. I found out that I hadn’t written much. So why now, almost 26 years later do I miss him? I feel like a fool. I’ve been trying to internet stalk him but I haven’t come up with much. Apparently he has a son who graduated high school and a girlfriend he has been with for about six years. They have a dog together. There’s a part of me that’s like, I don’t even know if he’d remember me. There’s another part like, girl, of course he remembers you. He was in legit love with you. And yet another part that’s like, hello? Why does any of this matter now? Answer. It really doesn’t. I’ve been taking Wellbutrin along with my Lexapro to try to combat my anxiety and depression. One of the side effects of Wellbutrin is insomnia. Joy. One of the side effects of insomnia is remembering things hat have been blocked from my memories. I’ve spoken before about my voluntary amnesia. I say it like a joke but it’s a real thing. I blocked out a lot of the Eric years. I cheated on him. He cheated on me. I had for real relationships with more than one person during that time with Eric. One of them was Bob.
I was working at a men’s clothing store. I worked a 12 hour shift by myself on March 10, 1994. My mom came by to bring me food. Three guys came in later. Bob, Shawn, and Brian. I had seen Brian before. Bob and Shawn were new. Bob started hitting on me right away. Making comments about getting caught up in my eyes. Do I have a boyfriend? While they were there, my friend Barb called. Bob took the phone from me and started talking to her about me. Telling her I have amazing legs. Then started asking her questions. Is my boyfriend big? Then he said if I was his girlfriend, there would be a ring on my finger. He continued to come to see me at work. Eric and I broke up on March 19th. I went out with Bob on March 20th. Though I don’t remember the sequence of my memories of Bob. I do have several. I remember the ease of being with him. It was like our souls and our bodies knew each other forever. I remember having sex in his truck and just feeling cherished and loved. I remember him coming to see me at work when I was there with my manager, Nick on more than one occasion. I was the assistant manager. So Bob would be there when my shift was over and Nick’s was starting. After about the third time, Nick raised his eyebrows (or one, Nick was one of those one eyebrow raisers) because he didn’t like Eric either. Eric and I always got back together. But that breakup on March 19th. I went to pool league (Eric and I were in a league together) and he kept trying to talk to me. I didn’t want him to. I called my mom and asked her to come get me and Bob came to pick me up shortly after. I ended up back together with Eric I’m sure it was less than a week later. But Bob kept coming around. I wanted him to. I really liked him. Like a lot. I went to his house once. I met his snake, Diablo. And learned that he wore pantyhose when he went hunting (“because they’re warm”). He came to see me at work one night right before I was closing up and put what appeared to be an empty Pepsi bottle on the counter. I went to throw it away and he was all “don’t throw him away!” He brought me a tiny little white mouse. He bred them for his snake. The breeders were named Bitch and Balls. He thought this one was cute so he gave him to me. I named him Buddy and had him for a year and a half. He was awesome. Bob wasn’t 21 yet so we would just sit and talk in his truck. I don’t remember what we would talk about. Just everything. Eric and I got engaged in May. Bob was heartbroken. But he still came to see me. He still called me. We were sitting in his truck one day and he said his friends kept telling him to stop coming to see me. But he said he couldn’t. He didn’t want to. He wanted me however I would let him. He made me a mixtape. I made him one too. The songs I remember that were on the one he gave me were “Baby Blue” by Badfinger and “Come on inside” by Izzy Straddlin. I don’t remember what songs were on the one I made except “Runaway Train” by Soul Asylum. He turned 21 on July 30, 1995. Our after work conversations moved from our cars to bars. I remember sitting at a table across from him and him reaching for my hand. It felt so perfect, I ached. I remember one time drinking with him and talking about feelings and being drunk and telling him I had to go because I wanted him and I wasn’t sure how much longer I could stop myself. I had to pull over on the way home to pee. There was so much snow.
This is the sequence I’m not clear on. But I think it went like this.
I met him at a bar... like a VFW type bar. We had sex outside by a lake or pond or something. Someone’s yard?
I got married in August of ’95. He bought me a sunflower throw blanket as a wedding gift. (I still have it.)
I met him at a bar and Nick was bartending. His hair was black.
I was at a bar with my sister and brother-in-law and Kristin. Bob was there. We played pool. He asked me to dance. I did. I wish I remembered what song. I feel like it was Wonderful Tonight. Kristin was staying at my house. Eric was in Atlantic City for pool league. So this would have been March or May ‘96. Bob came over. Kristin went to bed. Bob and I hung out in the living room. Things started happening... as was inevitable because we were so good together. Andy called. I hurried him off the phone. Bob asked if it was Eric. We went back to business. Then Eric called. I was naked. Off the phone and back to Bob. The sex that night was incredible. Easily the best sex of my life. By a large margin. Sweaty naked pounding long multiple orgasm multiple times. We’d finish and lay there wrapped up in each other until it was time to go again. I remember him saying that was how it should be. And I remember my arms around his neck not wanting to let go. To this day, I know Kristin had to have heard us but neither of us has ever mentioned it.
His dad died (shot himself in the head) and he called me. We sat outside on the sidewalk and he cried to me about his dad and about us. And god I loved him I did. I wish I would have told him. I wish I would have chosen him.
We were so close and so familiar.
I think it’s possible that part of my amnesia from that time was due to him. Because I broke his heart. And in doing so, I destroyed my life.
We’re different people now. But I wonder who I would be today if I didn’t, for whatever stupid fucked up reason, choose Eric time and time again. Who would I be if I’d have chosen Bob.
Where did all these memories come from? How do I make them stop? Do I want them to?